Ethical issues in chemical castration treatments of offenders essay
The importance of applying chemical castration as a legal sanction in our country, which is one of the treatment options for sex offenders and is practiced in various parts of the world, has increased. In several jurisdictions, sex offenders may be offered chemical castration as an alternative. to further incarceration. In some cases, consent to chemical castration may be made a formal condition of parole or release. In other countries, refusal to undergo chemical castration can increase the likelihood of further incarceration, even if there is no formal link. This article discusses ethical considerations regarding the practice of chemical castration for sex offenders and suggests that traditional treatments for rehabilitation including cognitive behavioral therapy and SSRIs have shown only minimal success rates and incarceration is costly to the state. ExpandChemical Castration of Sex Offenders: The Use of Depo-Provera in the Treatment of Sex Offenders. The legal issues. Demsky LS. J Leg Med, 5 2 Cited by: PMID: 6235301. Legal and ethical issues in the use of antiandrogens in the treatment of sex offenders. Melella JT, Travin S, Cullen K. Bull Am. Chemical castration effectively reduces recidivism when offered to sex offenders in the context of concurrent, comprehensive psychotherapeutic treatment. However, under current law, chemical castration sits vaguely between punishment and treatment, due to a lack of informed consent from the recipient. In Florida, Belgium and some other jurisdictions, chemical castration may be offered to sex offenders as either a formal or de facto alternative to further incarceration: Offenders may be given the choice between chemical castration and certain or possible further incarceration. A common objection to offering: In several jurisdictions, sex offenders may be offered chemical castration as an alternative to further incarceration. In some cases, consent to chemical castration may be made a formal condition of parole or release. In other cases, refusal to undergo chemical castration may increase the likelihood of further incarceration, even if there is no formal connection. Chemical Castration of Child Molesters Published: 12:33 PM EDT. The public debate on the ethical problems caused by medical punishment should be fueled by. Social problems include that chemical castration cannot guarantee human rights for involuntary cases performed without the informed consent of the sex offender, and thus can be considered as mere punishment and not treatment. Chemical castration has been performed without informed consent in Korea and in three states of Quot. Chemical castration for sex offenders. Legal and ethical issues in the use of antiandrogens in the treatment of sex offenders. Sentencing male sex offenders to use biological treatments. A constitutional analysis. Icenogle DL. J Leg Med, 15 2 279-304, 01 Cited by: PMID: 8057054. Review. Claim to. System. 1. The demand for prescribing anti-androgens or physical castration for sex offenders is a common response from lawmakers. and politicians when a high-profile sex crime is committed. A new issue has emerged in the bioethical debate about how extreme sex offenders can be prescribed to prevent new crimes when they are.